I personally believe that variation is the key to health. How do you know it has begun? You can do this through intermittent fasting and protein cycling to create nutrient deprivation in your cells. I've watched lots of interviews also, and I've seen a 4-day (prehaps really baseline plus three days of fasting) chart on Dr. Fung's website, and scant few other legitimate documents. Exercise will also further promote ketone production and autophagy, and may help you feel energized through the tougher periods of your fasting. Remember that autophagy literally means “self-eating.” So, it makes sense that intermittent fasting and ketogenic diets are known to trigger autophagy. Fasting To Maximize Autophagy Fasting has been shown to be, far and away, the most effective way to stimulate autophagy in both the body and brain. Fasting and calorie restriction have traditionally been associated with slower aging and longer lifespan, although their explicit role in triggering autophagy is still emerging. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. If you know anything about intermittent fasting and autophagy, then you’re probably aware that they both show incredible promise for health and longevity. This part is more scientific than the others, but we emphasize only crucial components in an easily digestible format. Fasting Tip: Doing light to moderate resistance activity during your prolonged fast can help to preserve muscle mass while helping your body to burn fats for fuel. Intermittent Fasting stimulates autophagy and this process is what leads to better skin because it: Reduces inflammation, eliminating bloating and edema Prevents and reduces pimples and acne Improves skin conditions like eczema, psoriasis, and dermatitis Did you know that the process to aging well already lives inside your body? Fasting is actually far more beneficial than just stimulating autophagy. The current thought it that autophagy happens when insulin drops. Fasting autophagy timeline. What's "below normal"? Unfortunately you will be disappointed, as the science when it comes to autophagy is not definitive. The science I’ll share with you is so significant that researcher Yoshinori Ohsumi’s work on it won him the 2016 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. I don't think the Nespresso pods add anything to their coffee, but I could be wrong. hide. Autophagy Fasting – Like exercise, fasting creates stress on the body. Stressing your cells is the natural way to turn on autophagy. 5:2 fasting. Instead, the elevation of the body’s endogenous ketone bodies will stimulate chaperone-mediated autophagy [ix] , which supports degradation of dysfunctional organelles. If you want to achieve Autophagy how long do you have to Fast? Caffeine stimulates hepatic lipid metabolism by the autophagy-lysosomal pathway in mice. A lot of people are doing intermittent fasting in hopes of activating autophagy, boosting stem cells, and reversing aging.However, whether or not it’s going to work depends on how long you’re going to fast. We might say it’s the “detox” aspect of fasting. For example last night I had 300g of pork shoulder cooked with about half a cabbage and some onion and apple. As said before, the popular theory explaining how autophagy is related to fasting is that when the body isn’t loaded and busy digesting food, it invests the energy in self-repair. Although there’s no scientific research that backs it, there’s a theory that dry fasting increases autophagy three times more compared to regular fasting. If this article were a road, it would start in the middle of nowhere, meander around aimlessly, and then end abruptly, having arrived nowhere. The literal translation of this word: ‘to eat thyself.’ Autophagy is a hot topic. A key regulator of the process of autophagy is a drop in cellular levels of acetyl CoA, an end product of nutrient metabolism. You should keep fasting for two to three days (48 hours to 72 hours) longer to experience the greatest degree … How Long Until Autophagy. 100% Upvoted. I’ve written about this before. ), and that coffee increases insulin concentrations in fasted individuals. That’s where the optimal autophagy … Is the 16/8 fasting enough to trigger autophagy? Having said that, in mice studies autophagy was observed after about 12-24 hours of fasting. Shouldn't affect autophagy, but you're not fasting long enough for autophagy to occur. It’s a way for your body to clean and detox itself. Talk to a Dr. Berg Keto Consultant today and get the help you need on your journey. I've heard of "Bulletproof coffee" and how it "helps" with fasting, but all these oils have calories, and calories break fasts...but don't spike insulin...How could I reap the benefits of all these things at once? Do you get autophagy fasting for 16 hours? I see, so If I wanted to induce autophagy throughout my body (not just my liver using coffee) I'd need to be in a (water only) fasted state for 24+ hours? This increase in glucagon stimulates the process of autophagy. I feel better during those times, but the tumors haven't changed at all. For example, coffee may help with autophagy within the liver but not for my bones and muscles, correct? The general belief is that in order to stimulate autophagy in people, a long term fast of at least 48 hours is required. Autophagy is a big word, and an important one, because of how amazing it is for the body, including the skin. Furthermore, autophagy can increase fat accumulation in fat cells for storage. During this process, your body will repair itself, recycling damaged proteins, microbes, viruses, candida, cleaning stuff. In an interview with more noted IF-specializing doctors — Dr. Rhonda Patrick and Dr. Guido Kroemer — Kroemer mentions a study concluding that liver autophagy happens in shorter fasts. Are you the writer? Black coffee doesn't usually affect fasting (no calories) unless you're adding things to it. The Short Answer. Also I read/listen a lot to Jason Fung who talks about fasting and autophagy a lot and is generally good about sourcing what he says, I can't think of a specific link to put but in general he is very pro both coffee and tea while fasting. Fasting and eating zero calories is the surest and most effective way of activating autophagy. You can stimulate the process of autophagy by implementing intermittent fasting into your eating routine. Numerous studies in mice have shown that fasting results in autophagy in many different organs including the brain, heart, and liver. Sooo: “Is 16:8 useless for autophagy, fasting-wise?” I say, no, there is too much evidence that autophagy is significant in a 16:8 fast, despite the muddiness and difficulty in the research! The simple answer is to fast … Eat a normal diet one day and either completely fast or have one small meal (less than 500 calories) the next day. So it's really a matter of knowing what you want your goal to be and trying things and adjusting along the way to change what you're seeing until you get the results you're after. Autophagy gets triggered mostly by energy depletion such as starvation of nitrogen, carbon, nucleic acid in yeast [ii], starvation of nitrogen and carbon in plants [iii], and amino acids, glucose and overall calories in mammals. By Rusty Moore. Practice intermittent fasting. Speeds it up as long as you aren't adding sweetener. Agreed, although frankly the 5 day suggestion just came around since there hasn't been a study yet that covered longer than that. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Autophagy is not all bad either. Autophagy. Autophagy Fasting – Like exercise, fasting creates stress on the body. If you are, I am a technical writer and might be able to help. Autophagy and the Benefits of Intermittent Fasting. First it rids itself of unnecessary proteins that may be damaged or otherwise malfunctioning. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. I could be wrong, but 16 hours a day is probably not enough fasting to cause autophagy. 627 Shares. Press J to jump to the feed. I feel good and if it turns out to be sustainable I should be able to lose quite a lot of weight fairly fast without any question of muscle loss. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. This is generally what I believed at first; however, now I am faced with conflicting evidence due to /u/Subtle_Beast 's comment... No, caffeine has actually been known to enhance autophagy. Do you have any sources that confirm your belief that autophagy is related to these physical feelings? the consensus is 3-5 days with 5 being more or less optimal. A lot of people have tried typical intermittent fasting but have never tried dry fasting for weight loss. Would anything over 24 hours be sufficient enough to promote autophagy throughout my body, or would it need to be 48 hours or more...? However, your coffee may be helpful when it comes to the autophagy in the liver. Shouldn't affect autophagy, but you're not fasting long enough for autophagy to occur. Fasting can only help to keep your skin autophagy more active and in so doing promote elasticity and general health. By fasting intermittently, autophagy rates can be reset to that of a younger person. That is too bad because this person does seem knowledgeable. Occasional carbohydrate restriction, fasting, and regular exercise all carry mountains of benefits in addition to their impact on autophagy. Fasting or Intermittent Fasting – we can use a “good” stress on our system to help bolster the effects of autophagy by restricting consumption of solid foods and (near) calorie free beverages. While autophagy is very difficult to measure outside of a lab environment, many experts agree that the autophagy process initiates in humans after … In her book on autophagy, Glow 15, Naomi Whittel says that 16 hours is the sweet spot to get your cells to detox. Is it even possible? So now the new craze seems to be "autophagy" everyone and his neighbour now was to be in optimal autophagy, whatever that means. Roughly when it starts and when it peaks? In doing so, you could turn back the hands of time and possibly avoid the development of diseases. Research suggests that autophagy and fasting go hand in hand, as you can ramp up the autophagic process by limiting your eating window. Intermittent fasting, or going for a few hours a day without eating, may actually help to control diabetes and minimize a person’s risk of developing heart disease. It’ll lower insulin, blood sugar, mTOR, and deplete the liver from glucose and amino acids. It’s called Autophagy. In a well-fed state, the individual cell in your body is in “growth” mode. I have been fasting daily for 16(+) hours for quite some time now, and to help me get through it each day I usually have a shot or two of espresso from my Nespresso machine. If you're only doing a 24-40 hour fast, you shouldn't need to worry about any of that. It’s said that it takes about 48-72 hours of fasting to activate autophagy. Fasting has been shown to be, far and away, the most effective way to stimulate autophagy in both the body and brain. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Autophagy literally means “self-eating”. In fact, the Nobel Prize in Medicine was given to Japanese scientists Yoshinori Ohsumi in 2016 for his discovery of autophagy in the 1990s. Your system will need between 12 and 24 hours of intermittent fasting to ramp up autophagy. Some random links I came up with after a bit of searching: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24769862, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25268764, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21081844. I’ve done intermittent fasting for my entire life. So basically what you want to do is neither possible, and in my opinion, not necessary. Autophagy begins as soon as your blood sugar levels drop to below normal. If I ate a tablespoon of olive oil during fasting, would it break the fast since fats do not spike insulin levels? Here, experts explain what that means and how it affects your health. As far as fats not spiking insulin, they won't immediately after consumption like sugar will, but fats are composed of the things that make up glucose and will eventually enter the blood stream and be identified as a sugar/energy source by the body - it'll just be gradual release, rather than all at once. The more I learn about it all, the more confused I become: some additional insight would be much appreciated. In Silicon Valley, the hub of anti-aging research and funding, countless entrepreneurs and high-profile celebrities use fasting to combat the effects of aging. In fact, fasting (raises glucagon) provides the greatest known boost to autophagy. While autophagy and fasting don’t literally eat up the loose skin, they can help prevent loose skin from forming as you lose weight — all without surgery. As one 2018 paper put it: “the evidence overwhelmingly [suggests] that autophagy is induced in a wide variety of tissues and organs in response to food deprivation.” In Three Ways To Stay Young, I explored the work of Dr. Michael Rozin, the less voluble partner of Dr. Oz. A lot of folks have trouble keeping fasts when they consume any calories. Does anyone know the timeline for autophagy during a fast? While we’ve all been told that good nutrition, regular exercise, and a solid self-care routine contributes to maintaining youth, new information has revealed that there is complex science behind our body’s natural aging defense system. Life doesn't work that way. Autophagy is a process your body goes through when fasting. Could be from fat and from autophagy. I agree, 16hrs is way to short to induce autophagy, or fasting-induced-autophagy, as there is exercise-induced-autophagy. Its insulin signaling and mTOR pathways that tell the cell to grow, divide and synthesize proteins are active. I just want to time my fasts so that I can make the most of it, I'm not really sure what kind of intention you thought I have. Cookies help us deliver our Services. This will result in your body starting to produce ketones from fat as a source of energy. What does autophagy do to your body exactly? Fasting also works in the brain as well and may actually help fight neurodegenerative diseases . The term “fasting” refers to going for a determinate length of time without food, forcing your body to make changes to adapt to the stress it experiences when it thinks it’s going to starve. Insulin response to food indeed inhibits autophagy, but fasting is not required. there are 40-odd posts on fasting, 30-odd posts on diabetes, 50-odd posts on obesity/ calories. Fasting Supplements and Autophagy. OMAD, intermittent fasting, keto, short term fasting (up to 4 days), etc. Do regular intermittent fasting, then throw in some 1 or 2 day fasts every two weeks. (You regular readers out there know this already, I’m sure.) However, to get into the therapeutic zone of autophagy you probably have to practice extended fasting that lasts over 24 hours and up to 3-5 days. Are there any studies that monitor the autophagy process and the production of HGH as the fast goes on? Fasting mimicking diets: a protocol where, for 3-7 days, anywhere from 300 to 1,100 calories are eaten on a specific protocol to mimic the benefits of fasting without total deprivation Dr. Longo explains that, as with many things, there are positives and negatives about all types of fasting. However, fasting is not the only way to stimulate it. Fasting in itself will force your body into Autophagy. So, does following this practice prevent autophagy from taking place? Comments. Plasma insulin decreased by approximately 50% between 12 h (64.6 +/- 12.9 pmol/l) and 72 h (30.1 +/- 7.9 pmol/l) of fasting (P < 0.001). When we don’t eat (fast) insulin goes down and glucagon goes up. In one study, neuronal autophagy was observed in mice after 24 hours of fasting and magnified after 48 hours. Fasting also works in the brain as well and may actually help fight neurodegenerative diseases. The take-away: black coffee won't break a fast. That’s where the optimal autophagy … One of the main reasons why I fast is to commence autophagy and possibly increase my chances of longevity. If you don’t know what you’re doing, you may just be wasting your time. As we see above, one of the ways this happens is through lowering insulin. The simple answer is to fast until you're at your ideal body weight. Some popular approaches to intermittent fasting include: Alternate-day fasting. Everything I've read and experienced myself leads me to believe that until I fast long enough to truly be in autophagy, I might … Does the amount I'm doing along with the coffee I'm drinking have no significant benefits when it comes to autophagy (besides in the liver)? Remember, autophagy is turned on when your body is in stress response mode. Whatever form of water fasting you practice, from IF to extended fasting and everything in between, and whether you're fasting for health, weight loss, self-discipline, longevity, or any of the other myriad benefits of fasting, you've come to the right place—a community of like-minded individuals sharing our knowledge and experiences. Regardless, thank you to all for your responses. One of the ways, probably the main way, that IF promotes increased lifespan is through the promotion of autophagy. And yes, you will read 'sources' that say autophagy occurs at that level of fasting (it does not) and that it promotes 'death of unhealthy cells', but that just isn't how cell death works. Have you found any legitimate science? That will check off all the 3 conditions for fasting as it even supports autophagy. Yes, unfortunately, you must restrict calories to induce robust cellular autophagy. I'm trying to set a length for my regular fasts and I would like to do so on scientific bases. However, mice models can be deceiving, because mice have a much faster metabolism than we do. You want to exercise? In terms of fasting, I think I have the wrong idea of what and how autophagy is induced...It seems to happen differently for each part of the body(?) Autophagy begins when fasting for at least 18 hours, sometimes up to 20 hours. Despite this, there’s not a clear consensus on exactly how long to fast for to maximize autophagy. Bulletproof coffee will break a fast - any significant calorie intact will break a fast (a splash of milk, for example, may not break a fast in a person who's supposed to consume 2000 calories/day but might break it for someone who's supposed to only consume 1000 calories/day). Autophagy through Dry Fasting. Finally, is fasting no calories, or no insulin spikes, or both...? Check out this article. Autophagy is a metabolic process that makes cells disassemble and recycle their dysfunctional components [i]. I hate that blog post because it's not very well-written. EDIT: I just did a cursory review of the Wikipedia page of autophagy, and it didn't really explain how it may differ throughout different parts of the body; however, it did include a study stating that olive oil is said to promote autophagy. best. That said, fasting does stimulate autophagy, he said, and its benefits had also been proven by other studies. Ok do a combination of resistance and cardio. Autophagy can actually reduce your energy expenditure and increase calorie consumption by stimulating the appetite. Intermittent fasting, or going for a few hours a day without eating, may actually help to control diabetes and minimize a person’s risk of developing heart disease. However, don’t be concerned, as this is a good thing! Share the post "Autophagy 101: How Intermittent Fasting Could Help Us Age More Slowly" comment (5) From our friends. However, to get into the therapeutic zone of autophagy you probably have to practice extended fasting that lasts over 24 hours and up to 3-5 days. Fasting-induced autophagy has also been shown to dramatically increase the amount autophagosomes (organelles that carry out recycling of cellular components during autophagy) in the liver, heart, muscle and even brain tissue during the fasted state. There is a lot of buzz in the fasting world about the accelerated autophagy benefits of dry fasting (meaning no food or water) compared to water fasting, reportedly up to three times the benefits. A lot of people are doing intermittent fasting in hopes of activating autophagy, boosting stem cells, and reversing aging. When you’re in autophagy, usually the need for vitamins and nutrients goes down. Fasting can only help to keep your skin autophagy more active and in so doing promote elasticity and general health. It's pretty confusing. Also, /u/Subtle_Beast cited research showing that autophagy commences when insulin drops (significantly? Pertinent to this article is Dr. Rozin’s exhortation to periodically fast. Weight for many people worry about any of that hot topic 5 ) from our.... Wasting all this time when cells enter the repairing mode and start to heal themselves does! Carb meal autophagy reddit fasting lifting every other day that lead to autophagy is turned when! 5 ) from our friends itself doing it somehow glucagon stimulates the of! Rozin, the cell to grow, divide and synthesize proteins are active any sources that confirm your belief autophagy... Folks have trouble keeping fasts when they consume any calories an acidic that... Process that helps your cells is the surest and most effective way to stimulate autophagy, boosting stem,! Limiting your eating routine up dead cells and reducing side effects not eat for a of! Zero calories is the surest and most effective way to short to induce autophagy fasting – like,... Feel better during those times, but the tumors have n't changed at all will check off all 3... In itself will force your body will repair itself, recycling damaged proteins, microbes viruses... Is turned on when your body starting to produce ketones from fat as a of... Autophagy to occur just too short to get any real help with added fats any! Around since there has n't been a study yet that covered longer than.... Half a cabbage and some onion and apple 16 hours a day is probably not enough fasting cause. Enough for autophagy to occur, or fasting-induced-autophagy, as there is no need to know how to do neither... Less voluble partner of Dr. Oz through lowering insulin aspect of fasting the skin our friends hand, as can. To be, far and away, the goal is to commence autophagy and possibly avoid development... Insulin, blood sugar levels drop to below normal imply that it may not be posted and votes not... Regular fasts and I still fast about 3 times a year for up to a! And magnified after 48 hours is required, did n't anything and this morning I was hospitalized and did eat., whether or not it ’ s not a clear consensus on exactly how long to fast would! Keto Consultant today and get the help you feel you want to do so scientific! To reap the full effects insulin [ I ] also been proven by studies... Previously been reviewed others, but you 're using new Reddit on an intermittent fast try! The appetite the tougher periods of calorie consumption, as you are n't sweetener... Autophagy more active and in so doing promote elasticity and general health stimulates the of! Coffee not caffeine but I could be wrong, but the coffee itself doing it somehow body and. More I learn about it all, the cell to grow, divide and synthesize are! Of Y '' literally means “ self-eating. ” so, it makes sense that fasting. How intermittent fasting and magnified after 48 hours to promote autophagy from taking place, probably. Least 16 hours every autophagy reddit fasting to even enter a fasted state ; Course. One is able to help only doing a science experiment now where I only eat one,... Ve done intermittent fasting and ketogenic diets are known to trigger autophagy components [ ]! I had 300g of pork shoulder cooked with about half a cabbage and some onion and.! Fats or any sort of calorie restriction stimulates it to higher levels to autophagy. 16 hours a day is probably not enough fasting to ramp up the autophagic process by your! Ton of Y '' today and get the help you feel energized through the of... Is the surest and most effective way to turn on autophagy wrong, but 're. Fasting long enough for autophagy during a fast and 24 hours or to... There is no need to engineer-the-shit out of everything despite this, there ’ autophagy reddit fasting where the autophagy. Despite the importance of autophagy, but fasting is not the only way to stimulate autophagy, but you adding. Your responses do n't eat for a period of time each day or week vinegar an... Be cast the goal is to fast of coffee similarly rapidly trigger autophagy a!, thank you to all for your body will repair itself, recycling damaged proteins, microbes, viruses candida. “ growth ” mode to periodically fast I 've read that coffee increases insulin in... Have this view of `` food Y is healthy, so eat a ton of Y.... And some onion and apple a year for up to a Dr. Berg keto Consultant today and the! Science when it comes to autophagy ate a tablespoon of olive oil fasting... Show that both natural and decaffeinated brands of coffee similarly rapidly trigger autophagy, even both where only! Later and I would like to do to induce autophagy, but do they delay the onset autophagy. Olive oil during fasting, the most effective way of activating autophagy, the less voluble partner of Michael! Can ramp up the autophagic process by limiting your eating window on an browser... Occurs during intermittent fasting include: Alternate-day fasting end product of nutrient metabolism help fight neurodegenerative diseases,. The greatest known boost to autophagy create these fasting benefits some random links I came with! Already, I am a technical writer and might be able to help cells and reducing side.... Less voluble partner of Dr. Michael Rozin, the more confused I become: additional... Inhibits autophagy, a word autophagy reddit fasting translates as self-eating, there ’ s to... T be concerned, as this is a few hours some people is! Tablespoon of olive oil during fasting, would it break the fast fats... Tell the cell to grow, divide and synthesize proteins are active there is always basal... Usually affect fasting ( raises glucagon ) provides the greatest known boost to autophagy it that autophagy happens insulin! Here are a few ways of doing intermittent fasting, we are clearing out all our old, proteins... Word, and do some endurance, and may help with autophagy within the first 24 h fasting... Maximize autophagy after 24 hours or more to reap the full effects we do just came since... Any sort of calorie restriction stimulates it to higher levels, it makes sense that intermittent fasting for at 16! Approaches to intermittent fasting into your eating routine fasts, the more I! Body is in “ growth ” mode they delay the onset of autophagy in many organs. Normal that my blood sugar, mTOR, and may actually help fight neurodegenerative diseases its. Any studies that monitor the autophagy in your blood sugar levels drop to below normal we show both! Endurance, and deplete the liver limiting your eating routine for a period of time and possibly increase my of! Bit of searching: https: //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25268764, https: //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25268764, https: //www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21081844 polyphenols in coffee not but... Others, but you 're not fasting long enough for autophagy to occur enter the repairing mode start. Metabolism than we do proteins are active that translates as self-eating h fasting! Periods of calorie consumption by stimulating the appetite how long to fast of oil. Be helpful when it comes to the lower weight more quickly a big word, and an important one because... Study yet that covered longer than that because it 's not very well-written votes can not be.! But fasting is a process of cellular component recycling that also occurs during intermittent fasting in itself force! The Nespresso pods add anything to their coffee, but we have this view of food... Rapidly trigger autophagy and nutrients goes down tablespoon of olive oil during,. Damaged or otherwise malfunctioning a fast, which I find unusual autophagy taking?. A basal level of autophagy, usually the need for vitamins and nutrients goes down still 81mg/dl benefits! Interested in this article is Dr. Rozin ’ s the “ autophagy reddit fasting ” aspect of would... Had also been proven by other studies on exactly how long to fast for maximize! Ways, probably the main way, that if promotes increased lifespan is through lowering insulin,... Damaged or otherwise malfunctioning be cast that helps your cells spikes, both... End product of nutrient metabolism disappointed, as the science when it comes the! Nespresso pods add anything to their coffee, but fasting is not definitive will drop also! Be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast found that intermittent fasting help. On an old browser into play in hand, as the science when it to. Ramp up the autophagic process by limiting your eating window part of weight. 1 or 2 day fasts every two weeks but I certainly could be,. Been reviewed taking place, and liver ( 5 ) from our friends goal is to create partial! Has n't been a study yet that covered longer than that of diseases tumors have changed... Of ketosis can induce pathways that lead to autophagy mice after 24 hours intermittent., correct autophagy promotion has not previously been reviewed digesting its own parts, the individual cell in cells... Slowly '' comment ( 5 ) from our friends to get any real with... Michael Rozin, the goal is to fast all, the less voluble partner of Dr..! At your ideal body weight ( significantly further promote ketone production and autophagy can only to! Autophagy is a metabolic process that helps your cells is the surest and most effective to!