It was developed by Crucible Industries and famous knife maker Chris Reeve, and the result was a super steel with great edge retention that is one of the best steels for EDC knives. "logo": { Among them, the choice of the blade material is arguably the most important one. VG10 isn't the easiest steel to grind or machine and is also fairly expensive, but is still cheaper than S30V. It's the heat treat that makes a difference. On January 15, 2020 Spyderco announced [1] knives being produced in a new steel: CPM SPY27, a steel produced by … The comparison between the two is tough. I am curious...both steels get such great reviews, based on the heat treatment etc...that Spyderco uses on both steels, how far behind S30V is VG10 in overall performance etc...? I believe that "true religion" in knives is recognizing that there are many good steels, and each has its own strengths and weaknesses which lead to different ideal applications. I believe it's better against corrosion but a little less "tough". Not very much. "datePublished": "2021-01-04", http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showt ... p?t=792540, http://www.youtube.com/user/mwvanwyk/videos. There is no "true religion" in steels. At least that's how it is for me. Learn more. I think that VG10 is pretty much the best "general use" steel out there. } Yojimbo™ 2 G-10 Brown Black Blade CPM S90V Exclusive. Crosscheck it wit. He hopes for all readers to gain useful and practical knowledge for enjoying their time outdoors. VG10 steel is considered a high-carbon steel. "image": { We want great knives, not just great steel or even great blades. Yes ^^^ I should have added above that even the greatest steel that has the best possible heat treat, grind and sharpening will be a lousy knife if the lock doesn't work well or easily and the handle doesn't fit/work well. Kyoku knives are made from the best materials and feature stunning blade designs. However, some food for thought, I think personally it all comes down to what you find easiest to sharpen (if one is a new knife user). But if you are looking for a fair and average EDC knife, S30V and VG 10 have an excellent chance to meet your needs. "sameAs": The S30V price tag is also quite substantial, which means that your budget may not always be suitable to make the purchase. Produced by Takefu Special Steel in Japan, it’s good all-around steel with a comfortable price for the general public. Vg-10 and n690 are chemically the same steel. Pro 1000. Well, in that case, this article will be handy for you. This is a non-powder Japanese steel used primarily in Spyderco … S30V vs VG-10. Cedric & Ada Gear and Outdoors just put up a video today. The carbon aspect is minuscule in the blade’s makeup, however. Archived. Takes a great edge easily, holds it pretty well, is tough (not prone to chipping), good corrosion resistance and has a nice luster. S30V is more of a steel nuts steel, most people with S30V can sharpen a knife. In the end, the primary function of a knife lies within its blade. Each steel choice is unique and suitable for a wide range of uses and working conditions. As from features, VG10 steel is the best balanced blade steel for everyone. 1%. ", Developed by Crucible, S30V has become the standard steel for a knife blade thanks to its admirable features. Martensitic is a specific type of stainless steel alloy. Jasně předčila ve většině nožířských zkoušek oceli 420J2, AUS4-A i AUS8-A. However, because VG10 has this minute amount of carbon, as well as minuscule amounts of chromium, molybednum, and cobalt, it contributes a chemical makeup that allows the knife to hold a superior edge. VG-10 is my all around favorite stainless because of its great balanced performance. Some people like to trade off the lack of edge rolling and say S30V will chip, but i haven't had a single issue with chipping the edge. Here's an approximate rating chart for edge retention: Also, I'd like to know which is the One True Religion. The innovative and unique mixture of alloy keeps the price down but ensures that its performance is still admirable. VG-10 "wins", not necessarily because it's the "better" steel, but because it's the steel the knives I like the best use. You can say that the VG 10 is more or … Comparing the Magnum 7mm vs. 30-06 Springfield, Reviewing the Lee Loadmaster vs. S30V is also expensive and notoriously difficult to machine and grind which means that it can be hard to sharpen if you let the edge go too long. "width": "1500", Cara Cara Rescue™ 2 FRN Black. Posted by. ", After spending most of his career as a firearms expert and instructor in Nebraska, he retreated to the great outdoors to enjoy retirement. VG 10 also uses a small amount of Vanadium in its composition, although not to the level of S30V. It's also a bit of a false comparison because S30V is used on American-made knives and VG-10 is used on Japanese-made knives - so they tend to be used on completely different models of knife. None are available in both steels, so unless you're buying a knife just to get a certain steel, rather than buying it because you like the knife, you really don't have a choice. VG10 ist eine rostfreie Stahlsorte mit einem für rostfreien Stahl hohen Kohlenstoffgehalt, nämlich 1 %. VG10 (V-Gold 10) - stainless steel. Neither has any big problems so just buy the knife you want, My spydies: Squeak, Tenacious, Terzuola, D'Allara, UKPK CF peel-ply pre-production, UKPK CF smooth pre-production, UKPK G10 orange leaf-blade, UKPK FRN grey drop-point, UKPK FRN maroon leaf-blade, Bug ... all PE blades. S30V vs. S35VN Steel: Differences and Advantages of Each. Just go over our comparison between S30V vs. VG 10 above so that you can finally decide what type of steel you need for your knife. $104.95. Crosscheck it with your preferences, and you can make up your mind on which one is better. What Is VG10 Steel? Like many other fellow Spydie-owners have explained, both steels are favorable for different reasons. When you buy something, you always want it to last for a long time, is affordable, and performs great for its purposes. At least that's what I want...YMMV. }, S30V offers a supreme combination of edge retention, ductility, hardness, toughness, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance. While there are many other high ends steels with competitive performances in the market, the S30V is still an excellent choice for a knife. VG10 is a more newbie friendly steel offering good performance while still being easy to sharpen. S30V is one of the most popular steels for high end knives. You can read those experiments here.. History. $237.95. For me it is a coin toss, both do what I want extremely well. Nowadays, you will find various options when it comes to blade steel, which may slightly confuse you. S30V and VG 10 are great materials for a knife blade, but it’s up to you to decide which one is better. It remains a favorite choice for a blade material besides late – invented steels. "@type": "Article", Love the way it is so easy to sharpen and touch up. CPM-S35VN is the new, upgraded brother of S30V. How often will you use the knife? They're both non powdered mid tier steels, and I honestly see zero difference between the two. I too have noticed what some others have posted: That S30V looses that ultra-fine edge very quickly, while still being pretty darn sharp, and staying that way for a while. My EDC tasks do not require a steel that keeps a working edge for a long time. 米国クルーシブ社でナイフ用に開発されたステンレス鋼材。440c鋼材と同等あるいはそれ以上の耐食性（錆にくさ）でありながら、刃持ちは440cを大きく上回るバランスの良い高級鋼材です。 So the edge retention of BD1N seems to be right between those two Spyderco steel staples. VG 10 possesses everything that can make a right blade: Hard, strong, and can get extremely sharp. Should you need a solid, robust, and affordable knife, products that utilize the VG 10 will be sufficient. Souhrnně bych tedy hodnotil takto. Yojimbo™ 2 Natural G-10 CPM® M4 Black Blade Exclusive. A great blade in a poorly constructed or ergonomically challenged platform has little value. "https://twitter.com/Shoot1ngMystery", It's also something of a moot point, at least where Spyderco knives are concerned. Christopher Wade is a true outdoorsman. His testing system puts VG10 at 260, BD1N at 375, and S30V at 425. Advantages: Wear resistance, corrosion resistance. 7 years ago. The blades are all of similar widths, around 2.5 cm, give or take amm or two. "@type": "ImageObject", From what I've gathered from knife tests on a local board they are pretty similar. And it’s clear that VG10 is no longer state of the art steel. VG-10 gets my vote. "dateModified": "2021-02-07", VG10 is a stainless steel type with a - for stainless steel - high carbon percentage, i.e. $217.95. S30V was the upgrade to 154 CM steel, and VG-10 is usually about as good or better than 154 CM. Alongside edge geometry and design, blade steel is a critical element that determines how a knife performs. Post by BornIn1500 » Tue May 14, 2019 5:30 pm . "url": "https://mk0shootingmyst008bi.kinstacdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/VG10-Steel-vs.-S30V-Steel.jpg" For your folding knives, you can prefer steel with better edge retention. It was designed in conjunction with knife companies, knifemakers, and heat treaters to learn the properties that they wanted in a knife steel. h your preferences, and you can make up your mind on which one is better. Everything is a toss-up and there is no such thing as a free lunch. That is good all-around knife steel. What are the working conditions? The closer to 20 points the “better” the steel. And the kind of steel used to forge the blade will be an influential factor to that subject. The low-end models usually use 8Cr13MoV blades, which are easy to sharpen and quite durable. "https://www.pinterest.com/theshootingmystery/", "https://www.reddit.com/user/theshootingmystery" cpm-s30v 58-60hrc. While an expensive steel material, VG 10 cost is still more affordable than the S30V. They don’t appear to make Super Gold 1 anymore though it could be one of the other grades in the patent. }. a mix) of carbon and iron that is often enriched with other elements to improve certain characteristics depending on the desired application. They are both high ends steels, which are well known for their performance and durability. © 2020 All Rights Reserved by Shooting Mystery, In the end, the primary function of a knife lies within its blade. S30V definitely holds a working edge longer, and to me doesn't really take any more effort to sharpen. "mainEntityOfPage": "https://shootingmystery.com/vg10-steel-vs-s30v-steel-one-better-choice/", I have pretty much gaven up on non-premium knife steels - simply not worth having. S30V vs VG-10. It’s not prone to chippings as the S30V but tends to bends and rolls if improperly push. You can use this chart to try to find the best steel for you. Answer all of those questions, and you shall have a pretty good idea about what kind of steel you want. The complex forgings and consistent heat treat processes have quite an effect on the price, though. — Kingsley Amis. General resistance against corrosion and abrasion are excellent nonetheless. UK Penknife™ Red G-10 CPM S30V Exclusive. "publisher": { In head-to-head testing, you would struggle to discern a significant difference between the two knife steels, but under a microscope you will see improved toughness and sharpenability (S35VN is a dream to sharpen when compared to S110V). Overall knife ergos and construction must be important considerations along with the steel. "@type": "ImageObject", I dont have a plain edge VG10 so I cant really compare the two. Its ability to preserve the sharpness on the edge is good but not as good as the S30V. The use of Vanadium in the CPM S30V composition reinforces steel integrity and increases its sharpness. It usually heat-treated, so the blade is tough and strong, but that would cause some troubles later. It can be used on anything and will finish the job without fail. This makes VG10 harder than most stainless steel types. The cutting characteristics are very good and VG10 is easy to sharpen razor sharp. And that is pretty much everything. "description": "In this VG10 Steel vs S30V Steel review, we compare the similarities and differences between the two knives to help you discern which is better. One significant issue is the edge will eventually wear, and it will be tough to sharpen it back. I love my S30v blades, but I tend to perfer a "hair popping Edge" Therefore, I pretty much touch up my blades with the SM fine rods everyday. However through the width of the edge bevelon the F1, the S1 and WM are thinner, and thus have a more acutely formededge. You will be presented with information about two popular blade steels: the VG10 and the S30V. Shooting Mystery is an independent website that provides content for informational purposes only. CPM S30V is a premium grade steel, and that is why it is expensive. S30V was designed to offer a “balanced” stainless steel which could offer good grindability, toughness, corrosion resistance, and edge retention. Now-a-days I have knives out of 154CM, S30V (two different knives, including my current Large Sebenza), and BG-42 (small Sebenza), and so far I like BG-42 the best: wears best, holds edge longer. On the other hand, VG 10 performs adequately in most respects and appropriate for the average uses. Details on the knives used : As the Fällkniven knives S1 and WM have full convex grinds there is nodistinct secondary edge bevels. S30V Steel. The content is not meant to be a replacement for professional service advice. S30V has superior edge retention, excellent corrosion resistance, great toughness but it tends to chip when it fails, and is typically heat treated fairly hard. I have found threw my on experience that Superme working edge retention is not that important when you touch up your blades as much as I do. Yojimbo™ 2 Natural G-10 CPM M4 Exclusive. VG-10 exhibits many of the same qualities of 154CM with the largest difference being an increase in corrosion resistance. VG10 is easy to sharpen, especially when compared to super-steels like S30V. } For all its glass-smooth slices, VG10 needs regular maintenance. Several pieces of the collection will appeal to the next generation of 110 users including this 110 Folding Hunter Pro featuring upgraded S30V steel and nickel silver bolsters with black G10 handle scales. "If you can't annoy somebody, there's little point in writing." Employ especially on knives, its abilities to retain edge sharpness and resist rust are superb. However, if you have some extra cash, try to aim for the higher models which use CPM S30V or VG-10 blades. S30V holds an edge a bit longer but is harder to sharpen while VG-10 lasts a little less and is easier to sharpen. Knife making supplies. Steel is essentially an alloy (i.e. Its sharpening process is also much simpler and more comfortable to perform compared to super steels such as the S30V. Among the two, S30 has better edge retention, high durability, and excellent resistance against many things. "If you wish to live and thrive, let the spider run alive", "the perfect knife is the one in your hand, you should just learn how to use it. It’s not much easier to sharpen than S30V, despite being noticeably poorer in edge … Much like ATS34 or 154cm. At the end performance wise I think it all depends on your uses. V agresivitě řezu se VG-10 vyrovnávala i S30V. Její malou odolnost proti dynamickému namáhání potvrdily sekací zkoušky. By popular request I have created a steel chart, where I try to simply map out the relative merits of each steel. "@context": "http://schema.org/", The same can be said about a knife and its choice of blade material. Overall resistances toward abrasion, corrosion, and alike are also considerably enhanced as well. "@type": "Organization", VG10 is only slightly behind CPM-S30v in CATRA testing from the results Spyderco published a long time ago. VG-10 The Spyderco Dragonfly 2 is among many of the company’s VG-10 offerings. But after all, the steel you think is the best for your blade depends entirely on the current needs and requirements. You can find a quick comparison of their characteristics right below, so check it out. Update 3/10/2020: We did a range of experiments with SPY27 to supplement the estimates in this article. Chris Reeve Large Inkosi. Composition Comparison Graph For The Knife Steels Crucible CPM S30V, Bohler-Uddeholm N690, Takefu VG-10, Takefu VG10 Version 4.36 $269.95. Personally, I prefer VG10 over CPM S30V. There are a lot of things that can decide whether a knife is right for you or not. CPM S30V. "name": "Shooting Mystery", Their environment resistance, sharpness, and toughness will vary a lot from one to another. Many say this is Spyderco’s best pocket knife option on the market, and we have to agree – this knife easily rivals the performance of knives double its value. VG 10 can get extraordinarily sharp but also can’t hold the edge for long. Compared to the standard Delica or Endura’s VG-10 steel, the S30V is a pretty big upgrade. VG-10 je tvrdší, odolnější proti korozi, ale křehčí než VG-1. It does this (loses the fine edge quickly, and stays working sharp for a while) quicker that VG-10. Yojimbo™ 2 Carbon Fiber CPM 20CV Exclusive. It may not be the best in any single attribute but it has no weaknesses either. What it is: CPM S30V is a "Crucible Particle Metallurgy" stainless steel, widely regarded as a "super steel" for its properties and performance. That makes the choice very personal, and particular answers depend on individual usage patterns. "author": "Christopher Wade", However, because VG10 has this minute amount of carbon, as well as minuscule amounts of chromium, molybednum, and cobalt, it contributes a chemical makeup that allows the knife to hold a superior edge. Shooting Mystery is reader-supported. A ton of higher end makers use 690 and treat it more carefully than vg-10. Close. "height": "800", VG10 VS S30V; VG10 VS D2; VG10 VS S35VN; Conclusion; Reach your true potential; Reach your true potential; what is vg10 steel. Add in VG10's ability to keep its razor's edge for a bit longer and overall easier time of sharpening and it's a no-brainer for me. When speaking about VG-10 steel vs S30V, it can be said that these steels are both of the premium quality, but maybe VG-10 is a little worse than S30V … Third, Spyderco vs Kershaw knives are not necessarily the most beautiful knives, but their designs are among the most effective and functional. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. But, dont get me wrong if I where going on a vacation or somthing I might choose S30v. Spyderco Counterfeits, Clones, Replicas, etc.  Originally developed by both Chris Reeve (a world renowned knife maker) and Dick Barber of Crucible Industries, S30V is a martensitic powder-made stainless steel. VG10 (V-Gold 10) - stainless steel. Stropping and sharpening VG10 is very difficult. BD1N vs S30V vs VG10 interesting result from cut test. And the kind of, You can find a quick comparison of their characteristics right below, so check it out. By Larry Connelley When looking at quality American-made knives, you'll notice that S35VN and S30V steel are two of the more popular steels for knife blades. However, VG10 is a perfect steel, but we’ve seen it so much that it gets a little boring. You can say that the VG 10 is more or less a balanced, cost-effective material for general tasks. It did allow for quick sharpening, though. I've found that when really pushed hard, VG10 will roll or get a shiny edge, whereas S30V won't (or to say the least, not near as fast). In choosing the best pocket knife you should pay particular attention to the type of steel used in the blade. WTC # 1458 - 1504 - 1508 - Never Forget, Never Forgive! What are you going to use the knife for? "https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC6dwEQfHK1tk_ZeaA4PniOA/", If however you are of the "penis measuring club" S30V is widely considered to be "longer" by those who don't know much about steels. Christopher’s expertise in handling firearms and hunting gear are what propelled him to create the Shooting Mystery blog. Home > Knives > Steels. S30V is often used by production knife companies like Benchmade, Kershaw, Spyderco, and many more. The CPM S30V (an acronym for Crucible Particle Metallurgy) is a quality, high endurance steel of American origin. 0.95 … Get a free guide on Knife Sharpening to find out how you can achieve more. $329.95. Pro 1000, { Its a mistake to try and compare the two steels, as they are both very different and excellent in their own ways. Reprofiling takes a bit more work but nothing like ZDP-189. However, it’s still sufficient to turn the VG 10 into a durable material that can endure a lot of abuse. Re: Blade material: Sandvik 14C28N, VG10, 154CM, S30V? S30V Knife Steel. ], ", If you don't have anything good to say, then don't say anything at all, SHARPEN IT LIKE YOU LOVE IT, USE IT LIKE YOU HATE IT. [ To compensate for that, the VG 10 is much easier to sharpen, though. OTHER GEAR REVIEWS: Comparing the Magnum 7mm vs. 30-06 Springfield, Reviewing the Lee Loadmaster vs. How much are you willing to spend? Spyderco is a famous and respectable brand in the knife industry, and they employ VG 10 in some of their most popular products. "keywords": ["vg10 steel vs s30v"], If you compare the two steels by whittling sticks...which is something that shouldn't chip your edge at all, then you will definitely see that if both edges are sharpened to the same bevel degree, VG10 will get a shiny edge well before S30V will. There you have it – KnifeCenter’s top 5 sub-$100 knives with S30V or S35VN steel. Disadvantages: Relatively difficult to sharpen, can be prone to chipping in certain applications. While an expensive steel material, VG 10 cost is still more affordable than the S30V. With its 2% vanadium we would expect it to be a bit below Elmax, S30V, and S35VN, which is also where the estimate puts it. Thanks to ShavedAlpaca, giorgi chubinidze, and Сергей Якунин for becoming Knife Steel Nerds Patreon supporters!. … Postby Grego77 » Sun Feb 13, 2011 1:39 pm, Postby Tsujigiri » Sun Feb 13, 2011 2:00 pm, Postby dj moonbat » Sun Feb 13, 2011 2:06 pm, Postby psychophipps » Sun Feb 13, 2011 2:37 pm, Postby mongatu » Sun Feb 13, 2011 2:53 pm, Postby hunterseeker5 » Sun Feb 13, 2011 2:57 pm, Postby JNewell » Sun Feb 13, 2011 6:37 pm, Postby D1omedes » Sun Feb 13, 2011 6:49 pm, Postby camokid » Sun Feb 13, 2011 6:56 pm, Postby The Deacon » Sun Feb 13, 2011 7:20 pm, Postby JNewell » Sun Feb 13, 2011 7:33 pm, Postby camokid » Sun Feb 13, 2011 8:26 pm, Users browsing this forum: benben, Bing [Bot], blues, Buddafucco, Cambertree, Jablang, Lumpy620, Oran360, pittalas, Spydergirl88, TKCSA and 35 guests. "https://theshootingmystery.tumblr.com/", 8. CPM-S30V has become one of the most used premium steels on the market among knife manufacturers. It’s so costly that it will decide the price tag of whatever knife that utilizes it. VG10 VS Steel . I decided to do this on 20 point scale, where I assign a maximum of 5 points to the 4 categories of Ease of Sharpening, Toughness, Edge Retention and Corrosion Resistance. "https://www.facebook.com/Shooting-Mystery-110244180901951", Newbies find the steel a bit hard to sharpen in my experience (my friends complain they cant get it sharp). S30v does hold a longer "working edge" when compared to VG-10. Its sharpening process is also much simpler and more comfortable to perform compared to super steels such as the S30V. "url": "https://mk0shootingmyst008bi.kinstacdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Shootinglogo.png" However, the S30V blade is more prone to chippings and quite expensive. When it come down to the line which do you perfer a S30v- "longer lasting edge" VS. VG-10-"great edge retention that is easier to sharpen" wonderful. "headline": "VG10 Steel vs S30V Steel: Which One is The Better Choice? Tsujigiri: Thanks for that link, , ,very interesting.